نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
The problem of evil is one of the fundamental challenges to theism in Islamic theology (Kalām) and Christian theology. The theory of "Compensations" (Aʿwāḍ) in the ʿAdliyya tradition is a response to natural evil and is based on God's compensation for initial sufferings. Using a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach, this paper first explains the capacities and shortcomings of this theory, then demonstrates that the concept of "Intiṣāf" (God's securing of the rights of the wronged from the wrongdoer) can fill the theoretical gap of Aʿwāḍ in covering moral evil. The combined system of "Aʿwāḍ + Intiṣāf" addresses natural evil through direct divine compensation and moral evil through the restitution of rights from the wrongdoer. Animal suffering is also analyzed under one of these two mechanisms based on the origin of the suffering. By presenting a rational argument for the necessity of Intiṣāf, the paper elevates this system to a robust theory. The distinction between "conceptual extension" and "similar function" in relation to Christian theology is analyzed, the system's capacity to counter the challenge of gratuitous evil is examined, and five main limitations are addressed with analytical responses. Finally, the relative superiority of this system over rival theories is demonstrated in terms of the comprehensiveness of explaining divine justice.
Keywords: Aʿwāḍ (Compensations), Intiṣāf (Restitution), Natural Evil, Moral Evil, Divine Justice.
کلیدواژهها English